{ "schema": "zerone.constructive-intelligence-life-sciences/v0", "status": "DRAFT", "mode": "SHADOW_ONLY", "authoritative": false, "networkObserved": false, "rewardBearing": false, "snapshotDate": "2026-08-01", "baseTreeBinding": { "schema": "zerone.constructive-intelligence-tree/v1", "sha256": "8070d8d1b7ea28a314f5a8550c675d7ccbe5d9b234ef02d54d4913c650c01aaf", "policyVersion": "1.0.0" }, "constitutionBinding": { "schema": "zerone.money-karma.constitution/v1", "documentSha256": "sha256:f22e62f0706971c569bb2156400b6dbeaf72a005d822b1e40c4e2691e7a98c24" }, "releaseBoundary": { "addsConsensusBehavior": false, "activatesRewards": false, "movesFunds": false, "grantsQualification": false, "grantsGovernanceAuthority": false, "createsKarmaMagnitude": false, "createsTransferableKarma": false, "authorizesExperiments": false, "authorizesClinicalDecisions": false, "performsNetworkRequests": false, "publishesRestrictedEvidence": false, "marksReleaseReady": false }, "economics": { "effect": "NONE", "amount": "0", "denom": null, "rewardMultiplier": false, "escrowReference": null }, "scope": { "riskClass": "GREEN_ONLY", "allowedWork": [ "benign-non-pathogenic-biomolecule-analysis", "benign-non-pathogenic-enzyme-analysis", "cell-free-expression-analysis", "in-silico-model-evaluation", "non-identifiable-aggregate-expression-analysis", "ordinary-low-risk-expression-analysis", "sanitized-metadata-only-replication" ], "refusedTopics": [ "CLINICAL_DECISIONS", "GERMLINE", "HOST_RANGE", "IDENTIFIABLE_HUMAN_DATA", "IMMUNE_EVASION", "OPERATIONAL_WET_LAB_ENABLEMENT", "PATHOGENS", "RAW_HUMAN_GENOME", "TOXINS", "VIRULENCE" ], "unknownRiskDisposition": "REFUSE_AND_ESCALATE_PRIVATELY", "privateEscalationContent": "NON_OPERATIONAL_METADATA_ONLY" }, "fixtureBoundary": { "syntheticIdentifiersOnly": true, "invalidTldRequired": true, "sequencePayloadsAllowed": false, "operationalProtocolsAllowed": false, "identifiableHumanDataAllowed": false, "rawHumanGenomeAllowed": false, "maximumArtifactMetadataBytes": 8192 }, "evidencePolicy": { "equivalenceToCoreTree": "NO_EQUIVALENCE_TO_E0_E6", "equivalenceToPoca": "NO_EQUIVALENCE_TO_POCA_TIERS", "ladder": [ { "level": "LS0", "name": "scope-and-risk-commitment", "economicTreatment": "NONE" }, { "level": "LS1", "name": "inspectable-provenance", "economicTreatment": "NONE" }, { "level": "LS2", "name": "bounded-method-check", "economicTreatment": "NONE" }, { "level": "LS3", "name": "independent-reproduction", "economicTreatment": "NONE" }, { "level": "LS4", "name": "prospective-or-adversarial-validation", "economicTreatment": "NONE" }, { "level": "LS5", "name": "independent-cross-context-replication", "economicTreatment": "NONE" } ] }, "independence": { "minimumEffectiveControlClusters": 3, "minimumOrganizationRoots": 2, "minimumMethodRoots": 2, "minimumContextRoots": 2, "rawIdentityCountIsEvidence": false, "beneficialControlDisclosureRequired": true, "futureEligibilityRequiresExternalControllerAttestation": true }, "challengePolicy": { "openChallengeRequired": true, "unresolvedChallengeBlocksCrown": true, "upheldChallengeBlocksCrown": true, "challengeCanCreateReward": false, "futureEligibilityRequiresAdjudicationReceipt": true }, "attestationBoundary": { "controlDisclosures": "SELF_DECLARED_SYNTHETIC_LABELS", "challengeStatus": "SELF_DECLARED_SYNTHETIC_LABEL", "establishesControllerIndependence": false, "establishesChallengeClosure": false }, "nonImplicationWalls": [ { "id": "ASSOCIATION_NOT_REGULATION_OR_CAUSALITY", "premise": "REGULATORY_ASSOCIATION", "doesNotEstablish": [ "CAUSAL_REGULATION" ] }, { "id": "INSILICO_NOT_PROSPECTIVE_EXPERIMENT", "premise": "IN_SILICO_PREDICTION", "doesNotEstablish": [ "PROSPECTIVE_VALIDATION" ] }, { "id": "MRNA_NOT_PROTEIN_ABUNDANCE_LOCALIZATION_OR_FUNCTION", "premise": "TRANSCRIPT_ABUNDANCE", "doesNotEstablish": [ "PROTEIN_ABUNDANCE", "PROTEIN_FUNCTION", "PROTEIN_LOCALIZATION" ] }, { "id": "STATIC_COORDINATES_NOT_FOLDING_PATHWAY_OR_KINETICS", "premise": "STATIC_STRUCTURE", "doesNotEstablish": [ "FOLDING_KINETICS", "FOLDING_PATHWAY" ] } ], "references": [ { "canonicalId": "casp:prediction-center", "authority": "CASP Prediction Center", "title": "Critical Assessment of protein Structure Prediction", "specification": "https://predictioncenter.org/" }, { "canonicalId": "ebi:miame-minseqe", "authority": "EMBL-EBI", "title": "MIAME and MINSEQE data-sharing guidance", "specification": "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/training/online/courses/functional-genomics-iii-submitting-data/what-kind-of-data-should-we-share/" }, { "canonicalId": "encode:data-standards", "authority": "ENCODE Project", "title": "ENCODE data standards", "specification": "https://www.encodeproject.org/data-standards/" }, { "canonicalId": "gene-ontology:evidence-codes", "authority": "Gene Ontology Consortium", "title": "Guide to Gene Ontology evidence codes", "specification": "https://geneontology.org/docs/guide-go-evidence-codes/" }, { "canonicalId": "ncbi:geo-hts", "authority": "NCBI", "title": "GEO high-throughput sequence submission guidance", "specification": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/info/seq.html" }, { "canonicalId": "ncbi:sra-metadata", "authority": "NCBI", "title": "Sequence Read Archive metadata guidance", "specification": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sra/docs/submitmeta/" }, { "canonicalId": "uniprot:uniprotkb", "authority": "UniProt Consortium", "title": "UniProt Knowledgebase", "specification": "https://www.uniprot.org/help/uniprotkb" }, { "canonicalId": "who:lab-biosafety-manual-4", "authority": "World Health Organization", "title": "Laboratory biosafety manual, fourth edition", "specification": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240011311" }, { "canonicalId": "wwpdb:pdbx-mmcif", "authority": "Worldwide Protein Data Bank", "title": "PDBx/mmCIF resources", "specification": "https://mmcif.wwpdb.org/" } ], "roots": [ "biomolecule-context-provenance@1", "study-provenance-controls@1" ], "nodes": [ { "id": "biomolecule-context-provenance@1", "title": "Biomolecule identity and context provenance", "stage": "foundation", "branch": "biomolecule-foundations", "summary": "Bind a benign biomolecule claim to a stable identifier, declared biological context, source provenance, and bounded intended interpretation.", "prerequisites": [], "evidenceFloor": "LS1", "claimClass": "CONTEXT_PROVENANCE", "permittedConclusions": [ "CONTEXT_PROVENANCE" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [], "artifactRequirements": [ "A stable public identifier or synthetic fixture identifier with source and version metadata.", "A declared organism-free or benign-context scope and an explicit statement of excluded interpretations.", "Digests for every public metadata artifact; no raw sequence payload is carried by the profile." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The identifier mapping, source edition, molecular context, or safety classification changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "uniprot:uniprotkb", "who:lab-biosafety-manual-4" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "biomolecule-function-annotation@1", "title": "Function annotation with evidence provenance", "stage": "measurement", "branch": "biomolecule-foundations", "summary": "Separate curated or computational annotation from direct functional measurement and preserve the evidence code behind each assertion.", "prerequisites": [ "biomolecule-context-provenance@1", "study-provenance-controls@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS2", "claimClass": "FUNCTION_ANNOTATION", "permittedConclusions": [ "ANNOTATED_FUNCTION" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [ "PROTEIN_FUNCTION" ], "artifactRequirements": [ "A version-pinned annotation record and its evidence classification.", "A machine-readable distinction between inferred annotation and measured function.", "A conflict report for contradictory annotations or obsolete identifiers." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The annotation, evidence code, source record, or identifier mapping changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "gene-ontology:evidence-codes", "uniprot:uniprotkb" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "expression-assay-design@1", "title": "Gene-expression assay design and metadata", "stage": "measurement", "branch": "gene-expression", "summary": "Freeze study design, controls, sample metadata categories, endpoints, exclusions, and analysis intent before interpreting expression measurements.", "prerequisites": [ "study-provenance-controls@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS1", "claimClass": "ASSAY_DESIGN", "permittedConclusions": [ "ASSAY_SCOPE" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [], "artifactRequirements": [ "A versioned design record covering controls, declared endpoints, exclusions, and metadata completeness.", "A de-identification statement limiting public evidence to non-identifiable aggregate or synthetic metadata.", "Repository-ready metadata shaped by applicable community submission guidance." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The cohort definition, context, endpoint, control plan, or metadata standard changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "ebi:miame-minseqe", "encode:data-standards", "ncbi:geo-hts", "ncbi:sra-metadata" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "expression-context-normalization@1", "title": "Expression context and normalization", "stage": "inference", "branch": "gene-expression", "summary": "Make comparison context, normalization choices, batch structure, exclusions, and uncertainty inspectable without treating preprocessing as biology.", "prerequisites": [ "expression-assay-design@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS2", "claimClass": "CONTEXT_NORMALIZATION", "permittedConclusions": [ "NORMALIZED_COMPARISON" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [], "artifactRequirements": [ "Pinned input-metadata and analysis-environment digests with a bounded comparison definition.", "A declared normalization and batch model with negative and sensitivity checks.", "An uncertainty report that separates processing effects from scoped biological interpretation." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The comparison set, normalization rule, batch model, exclusion rule, or analysis environment changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "ebi:miame-minseqe", "encode:data-standards", "ncbi:geo-hts" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "expression-protein-abundance-localization@1", "title": "Protein abundance and localization evidence", "stage": "validation", "branch": "gene-expression", "summary": "Require direct protein-level and localization evidence before advancing beyond transcript abundance, with context and uncertainty kept explicit.", "prerequisites": [ "biomolecule-function-annotation@1", "expression-transcript-quantification@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS3", "claimClass": "PROTEIN_MEASUREMENT", "permittedConclusions": [ "PROTEIN_ABUNDANCE", "PROTEIN_LOCALIZATION" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [ "PROTEIN_FUNCTION" ], "artifactRequirements": [ "Direct protein-level measurement metadata with controls and uncertainty.", "Localization-specific evidence when a localization conclusion is requested.", "An explicit comparison showing why transcript evidence alone is insufficient." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The measurement platform, detection model, localization method class, or biological context changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "gene-ontology:evidence-codes", "uniprot:uniprotkb" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "expression-regulatory-association@1", "title": "Regulatory association evidence", "stage": "validation", "branch": "gene-expression", "summary": "Record reproducible association under a frozen design while refusing to relabel correlation as regulation or causality.", "prerequisites": [ "expression-context-normalization@1", "expression-transcript-quantification@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS3", "claimClass": "REGULATORY_ASSOCIATION", "permittedConclusions": [ "REGULATORY_ASSOCIATION" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [ "CAUSAL_REGULATION" ], "artifactRequirements": [ "A frozen association model with covariates, denominator, exclusions, and uncertainty.", "Independent reproduction metadata from effectively distinct control clusters.", "A machine-readable non-causality label on every association-only result." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The population, context, covariates, denominator, association model, or exclusion rule changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "ebi:miame-minseqe", "encode:data-standards", "gene-ontology:evidence-codes" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "expression-regulatory-causality@1", "title": "Bounded regulatory causality", "stage": "validation", "branch": "gene-expression", "summary": "Advance from association only with bounded perturbational evidence, direct endpoints, prospective evaluation, and effective independent reproduction.", "prerequisites": [ "expression-protein-abundance-localization@1", "expression-regulatory-association@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS4", "claimClass": "REGULATORY_CAUSALITY", "permittedConclusions": [ "CAUSAL_REGULATION", "PROSPECTIVE_VALIDATION" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [], "artifactRequirements": [ "A preregistered bounded causal claim and prospectively frozen evaluation criteria.", "Perturbational evidence with direct molecular endpoints and declared negative controls.", "Independent reproduction across disclosed control, method, and context roots." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The intervention class, endpoint, context, model, control structure, or causal claim changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "encode:data-standards", "gene-ontology:evidence-codes", "who:lab-biosafety-manual-4" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "expression-transcript-quantification@1", "title": "Transcript quantification with uncertainty", "stage": "inference", "branch": "gene-expression", "summary": "Produce bounded transcript-abundance conclusions with complete metadata, controls, uncertainty, and an explicit wall against protein-level claims.", "prerequisites": [ "expression-context-normalization@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS2", "claimClass": "TRANSCRIPT_MEASUREMENT", "permittedConclusions": [ "TRANSCRIPT_ABUNDANCE" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [ "PROTEIN_ABUNDANCE", "PROTEIN_FUNCTION", "PROTEIN_LOCALIZATION" ], "artifactRequirements": [ "A bounded transcript-abundance result with denominator, uncertainty, and negative controls.", "Complete non-identifiable metadata sufficient to inspect processing and comparison context.", "An explicit statement that transcript abundance does not establish protein abundance, localization, or function." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The assay, quantification model, reference annotation, denominator, or comparison context changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "ebi:miame-minseqe", "encode:data-standards", "ncbi:geo-hts", "ncbi:sra-metadata" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "folding-calibrated-model@1", "title": "Calibrated fold-model evidence", "stage": "inference", "branch": "protein-folding", "summary": "Bind an in-silico structural model to input provenance, model and environment digests, calibration, and a scoped confidence statement.", "prerequisites": [ "structure-coordinate-evidence@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS2", "claimClass": "FOLD_MODEL", "permittedConclusions": [ "FOLD_MODEL_CONFIDENCE" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [ "FOLDING_KINETICS", "FOLDING_PATHWAY", "PROSPECTIVE_VALIDATION" ], "artifactRequirements": [ "Pinned model, parameter, input-metadata, and execution-environment digests.", "Calibration against a frozen benchmark or held-out class with bounded uncertainty.", "A statement separating predicted coordinates and confidence from folding mechanism, kinetics, and measured function." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The model, parameters, input metadata, benchmark, calibration method, or execution environment changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "casp:prediction-center", "wwpdb:pdbx-mmcif" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "folding-ensemble-uncertainty@1", "title": "Fold ensemble and uncertainty", "stage": "validation", "branch": "protein-folding", "summary": "Compare model ensembles and uncertainty under bounded assumptions without converting sampled conformations into an unsupported pathway or kinetic claim.", "prerequisites": [ "folding-calibrated-model@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS3", "claimClass": "FOLD_ENSEMBLE", "permittedConclusions": [ "FOLD_ENSEMBLE_UNCERTAINTY" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [ "FOLDING_KINETICS", "FOLDING_PATHWAY", "PROSPECTIVE_VALIDATION" ], "artifactRequirements": [ "A frozen ensemble definition with model-lineage, sampling, and environment digests.", "Uncertainty decomposition and sensitivity checks across effectively distinct methods.", "An explicit refusal to infer pathway or kinetics from static or sampled coordinates alone." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The ensemble, sampling assumptions, method lineage, calibration, or target context changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "casp:prediction-center", "wwpdb:pdbx-mmcif" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "folding-function-evidence@1", "title": "Fold-to-function evidence", "stage": "validation", "branch": "protein-folding", "summary": "Link a bounded structural hypothesis to direct functional evidence and prospective evaluation without allowing annotation or model confidence to substitute for function.", "prerequisites": [ "biomolecule-function-annotation@1", "folding-ensemble-uncertainty@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS4", "claimClass": "FOLD_FUNCTION", "permittedConclusions": [ "PROSPECTIVE_VALIDATION", "PROTEIN_FUNCTION" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [], "artifactRequirements": [ "A preregistered structural-to-functional claim with prospectively frozen evaluation criteria.", "Direct functional evidence, declared controls, uncertainty, and scope bounds.", "Independent reproduction that discloses control, method, and context roots." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The structural hypothesis, functional endpoint, context, control plan, or prospective criterion changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "gene-ontology:evidence-codes", "uniprot:uniprotkb", "who:lab-biosafety-manual-4", "wwpdb:pdbx-mmcif" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "folding-model-benchmarking@1", "title": "Blind and held-out fold-model benchmarking", "stage": "validation", "branch": "protein-folding", "summary": "Evaluate model performance on frozen blind or held-out targets, disclose lineage and leakage risks, and report failure classes rather than one headline score.", "prerequisites": [ "folding-calibrated-model@1", "study-provenance-controls@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS3", "claimClass": "FOLD_BENCHMARK", "permittedConclusions": [ "FOLD_MODEL_CONFIDENCE" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [ "FOLDING_KINETICS", "FOLDING_PATHWAY", "PROSPECTIVE_VALIDATION" ], "artifactRequirements": [ "A frozen target set, scoring definition, denominator, exclusions, and model cutoff.", "A leakage and lineage analysis covering training overlap, templates, tools, and shared infrastructure.", "Per-class uncertainty and failure reporting with an independently executable scoring artifact." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The target set, scoring rule, denominator, model cutoff, lineage disclosure, or benchmark status changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "casp:prediction-center", "wwpdb:pdbx-mmcif" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "integration-genotype-expression-phenotype@1", "title": "Genotype-to-expression-to-phenotype chain", "stage": "integration", "branch": "integration", "summary": "Join bounded causal expression evidence to a phenotype endpoint while preserving every context, denominator, uncertainty, and non-implication boundary.", "prerequisites": [ "expression-regulatory-causality@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS4", "claimClass": "GENOTYPE_EXPRESSION_PHENOTYPE", "permittedConclusions": [ "GENOTYPE_EXPRESSION_PHENOTYPE_CHAIN" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [], "artifactRequirements": [ "A graph of separately evidenced genotype, expression, protein, and phenotype links with no inferred edge hidden.", "Prospectively frozen endpoints, denominators, controls, uncertainty, and context bounds.", "Independent reproduction with conflict-cluster and method-lineage disclosure." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "Any linked claim, endpoint, denominator, context, causal model, or provenance record changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "encode:data-standards", "gene-ontology:evidence-codes", "uniprot:uniprotkb", "who:lab-biosafety-manual-4" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "integration-variant-fold-function@1", "title": "Variant-to-fold-to-function chain", "stage": "integration", "branch": "integration", "summary": "Join variant context, calibrated fold evidence, and prospective functional evidence without converting model confidence into biological function.", "prerequisites": [ "folding-function-evidence@1", "folding-model-benchmarking@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS4", "claimClass": "VARIANT_FOLD_FUNCTION", "permittedConclusions": [ "VARIANT_FOLD_FUNCTION_CHAIN" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [], "artifactRequirements": [ "A graph of separately evidenced variant, structure, model, and function links with explicit uncertainty at every edge.", "Prospectively frozen functional criteria and independent reproduction metadata.", "A lineage and leakage report spanning data, templates, models, tools, and control clusters." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The variant context, structural evidence, model, benchmark, functional endpoint, or lineage disclosure changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "casp:prediction-center", "gene-ontology:evidence-codes", "uniprot:uniprotkb", "wwpdb:pdbx-mmcif" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "replication-cross-context-crown@1", "title": "Independent cross-context replication crown", "stage": "crown", "branch": "integration", "summary": "Recognize only a shadow LS5 result reproduced across independent control, organization, method, and context roots after an open challenge clears.", "prerequisites": [ "integration-genotype-expression-phenotype@1", "integration-variant-fold-function@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS5", "claimClass": "CROSS_CONTEXT_REPLICATION", "permittedConclusions": [ "INDEPENDENT_CROSS_CONTEXT_REPLICATION" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [], "artifactRequirements": [ "At least three effective control clusters spanning at least two organization, method, and context roots.", "Frozen claims and evaluation criteria with separately attributable confirming and contradicting results.", "A clear challenge state; every open, unresolved, or upheld challenge blocks the crown.", "A machine-verifiable statement that the crown creates no reward, authority, qualification, or KARMA magnitude." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "A challenge opens, a conflict relationship is discovered, a replication is withdrawn, or any bound claim changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "casp:prediction-center", "ebi:miame-minseqe", "encode:data-standards", "gene-ontology:evidence-codes", "who:lab-biosafety-manual-4", "wwpdb:pdbx-mmcif" ], "crown": true }, { "id": "structure-coordinate-evidence@1", "title": "Static structure-coordinate evidence", "stage": "measurement", "branch": "protein-folding", "summary": "Bind static structural coordinates to format, provenance, method context, quality metadata, and an explicit refusal to infer pathway or kinetics.", "prerequisites": [ "biomolecule-context-provenance@1", "study-provenance-controls@1" ], "evidenceFloor": "LS2", "claimClass": "STATIC_STRUCTURE", "permittedConclusions": [ "STATIC_STRUCTURE" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [ "FOLDING_KINETICS", "FOLDING_PATHWAY" ], "artifactRequirements": [ "A format-valid coordinate artifact digest with source, method class, and quality metadata.", "A bounded mapping from stable biomolecule context to the coordinate record.", "An explicit statement that static coordinates do not establish a folding pathway or kinetics." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The coordinate record, source revision, quality metadata, method interpretation, or biomolecule mapping changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "wwpdb:pdbx-mmcif" ], "crown": false }, { "id": "study-provenance-controls@1", "title": "Study provenance, controls, and safety scope", "stage": "foundation", "branch": "biomolecule-foundations", "summary": "Freeze a GREEN-only question, prior evidence, denominator, controls, conflicts, safety exclusions, and bounded public metadata before analysis.", "prerequisites": [], "evidenceFloor": "LS0", "claimClass": "STUDY_PROVENANCE", "permittedConclusions": [ "STUDY_PROVENANCE" ], "forbiddenConclusions": [], "artifactRequirements": [ "A timestamped scope digest with declared question, denominator, exclusions, controls, conflicts, and stopping rules.", "A GREEN-only risk assessment that refuses every v0 RED topic and sends unknown risk to private metadata-only escalation.", "A public-artifact manifest containing synthetic or non-identifiable metadata only, with no sequence or operational protocol payload." ], "revalidationTriggers": [ "The question, denominator, control plan, conflict graph, public-data class, or risk classification changes." ], "referenceIds": [ "ebi:miame-minseqe", "encode:data-standards", "who:lab-biosafety-manual-4" ], "crown": false } ] }